研究与检索SKILL.md

文献综述整理

v1

围绕研究问题组织文献、比较方法和结论,保留引用与未解决问题。

Claude Code # 研究分析# Agent Skills# 文献阅读

技能概述

这项技能做什么

围绕研究问题组织文献、比较方法和结论,保留引用与未解决问题。

对应原始技能标识:litreview。本站整理中文说明,技能原文由 alirezarezvani/claude-skills 维护。

适用场景与输入

分类:研究与检索。建议准备:研究问题、已知资料、比较对象、证据范围和判断标准。

获取与使用

  1. 打开固定版本的完整技能目录,按仓库说明获取技能。
  2. 原目录包含 references、scripts 等配套资源。请获取完整技能目录,单独下载本站的 SKILL.md 不包含这些文件。
  3. 在 Claude Code 或具备相应工具能力的兼容 Agent 中加载;兼容 SKILL.md 格式不代表各平台工具完全一致。
  4. 参照页面的使用示例提供材料,按照原文步骤执行,并核对实际输出。

输出与验证

区分事实、假设与推断;按证据组织结论,列出局限和下一步验证建议。本站未执行来源仓库中的脚本,也不把示例当作已经完成的运行结果。

来源与许可

MIT License

Copyright (c) 2025 Alireza Rezvani

Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy
of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal
in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights
to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell
copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is
furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR
IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM,
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE
SOFTWARE.

如何使用这个 Skill

下载 SKILL.md,查看文件中的说明与依赖,再按你的 Agent 支持的方式导入。

SKILL.mdMarkdown · 1 个文件

SKILL.md

---
name: litreview
description: "Use when starting a literature review or a literature-based project. Plans the search (PICO, SPIDER) with framework_recommender.py, searches PubMed and OpenAlex with free_search.py and writes a .docx orientation guide. Single-paper lookups: query directly."
license: MIT
metadata:
  source_spec: "megaprompts/09-litreview-megaprompt.md"
  build_pattern: "Path B (direct conversion)"
  research_pack_convention: "Agent Integrity Rules verbatim per PR #657 audit; sibling of pulse"
  version: 1.1.0
---

# Litreview — Academic Literature Orientation

> **Portability:** Works anywhere with outbound HTTPS — the default search lane is **free keyless APIs** (PubMed E-utilities + OpenAlex, no account, no key, no MCP). The **Consensus MCP is an optional enhancement lane** used only when connected in this session. Node.js with `docx` package is required for document generation, and (in CLI) `bash_tool`. Works in Claude Code CLI natively and in Claude.ai with Code Execution.

Produce a **launching pad** — not a finished literature review, but an orientation document that gives a researcher entering an unfamiliar field everything they need to start reading and searching with confidence. Think: what a generous colleague who knows the field would tell you over coffee.

## Search Lanes

| Lane | When | How |
|---|---|---|
| **Free lane (default)** | Always available; no key, no plan, no MCP | PubMed E-utilities + OpenAlex via `scripts/free_search.py` or direct HTTPS (URL templates below) |
| **Consensus lane (optional enhancement)** | Only when Consensus MCP tools are available in this session | Run Consensus queries *in addition to* the free lane for its synthesized answer cards |

**Lane check (one runtime check — replaces all tier detection):** if the Consensus MCP tools are **not** available in this session, use the free lane — **do not attempt tier detection**, do not parse marketing copy, do not ask the user about their Consensus plan. If Consensus IS available, additionally run its searches and merge results (dedupe by DOI/title).

### Free-lane URL templates (exact)

**PubMed E-utilities** (keyless; etiquette: ≤3 requests/second):

1. Search → PMIDs: `https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esearch.fcgi?db=pubmed&term=<urlencoded-query>&retmode=json&retmax=20&sort=relevance`
   — read `esearchresult.idlist` (PMIDs) and `esearchresult.count`.
2. PMIDs → metadata: `https://eutils.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/eutils/esummary.fcgi?db=pubmed&id=<pmid1,pmid2,...>&retmode=json`
   — per `result[<pmid>]` read `title`, `authors[].name`, `pubdate`, `fulljournalname`, `articleids[]` (the `idtype: "doi"` entry).
3. Era-gating: append `&datetype=pdat&mindate=2021&maxdate=3000` (recent) or `&maxdate=2015` (historical).
4. Paper URL: `https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/<PMID>/`.

**OpenAlex** (keyless; add `&mailto=<email>` for the polite pool — faster + more reliable):

1. Search: `https://api.openalex.org/works?search=<urlencoded-query>&per-page=20&mailto=<email>`
   — per `results[]` read `display_name` (title), `publication_year`, `cited_by_count`, `doi`, `id` (OpenAlex URL), `authorships[].author.display_name`, `primary_location.source.display_name` (venue).
2. Era-gating: `&filter=from_publication_date:2021-01-01` or `&filter=to_publication_date:2015-12-31`.
3. Review articles: `&filter=type:review`.

OpenAlex's `cited_by_count` is the citation-count source for the cross-search intelligence layer (PubMed esummary returns no counts).

## Agent Integrity Rules (Research-Pack Convention)

Inherited from the research-pack convention; locked verbatim per PR #657's cross-skill consistency audit.

- **Source discipline.** Only cite papers returned by THIS session's searches (free lane and/or Consensus). Training knowledge labeled `[Not from search — model knowledge]` and excluded from cited count. Sparse results stated explicitly, never silently filled.
- **Counting discipline.** Three numbers tracked: searches executed / unique papers received (deduplicated by DOI/title) / papers cited. Every cited paper has a retrievable URL from this session (PubMed, DOI, OpenAlex, or Consensus). Use `scripts/citation_tracker.py` for deterministic counts.
- **Rate-limit etiquette.** PubMed E-utilities: ≤3 requests/second keyless. OpenAlex: polite pool via `mailto`. Consensus (if connected): 1 query/sec, sequential execution mandatory. Default discipline: **sequential, 1 query/sec across all lanes.**
- **Retry policy.** On failure → wait 3s → retry once → log. After 3 consecutive failures: stop, alert user, share what was collected.
- **Lane check.** One runtime check at session start: Consensus MCP tools available or not. No tier detection, ever.

See [`references/search_budget_allocation.md`](references/search_budget_allocation.md) for the sequential-execution rationale + budget ceilings.

## Error Handling

| Failure | Behavior |
|---|---|
| Rate-limit / HTTP error on any lane | Wait 3s, retry once, log outcome |
| Search returns 0 results | Note explicitly; "either niche terminology or genuine gap"; never silently fill |
| Network unavailable (free lane exits 2) | Stop, alert user — the free lane needs outbound HTTPS; nothing to detect or upgrade |
| 3 consecutive failures | Stop searching, alert user, share what's collected, ask how to proceed |
| Sub-area returns thin results (<5 papers) | Flag in audit; suggest manual Google Scholar / Scopus supplementation |
| User wants to adjust sub-areas | Update table, re-confirm before searching |
| DOCX validation fails | Unpack XML, fix, repack |

## Phase 0: Grill-Me Intake (3 forcing questions, one at a time)

Each question carries explicit "why I'm asking". Stop condition: max 3 before Phase 1.

### Q1 (root) — Research question specificity

> **State the research question in 1–2 sentences. Specific is better — "How do LLMs perform on clinical reasoning tasks compared to physicians?" beats "AI in medicine". Vague questions produce vague reviews.**
>
> *Why I'm asking:* The reconnaissance search hinges on precise terminology. Vague questions produce thin recon results that don't yield a useful framework breakdown.

**Refuse mush.** Re-ask once with examples if user is too broad. If still vague, deliver with explicit "broad-scope orientation, not depth review" caveat.

### Q2 (depends on Q1) — Framework hint

> **Framework — pick one or say "you pick":**
>
> 1. **PICO** (Population / Intervention / Comparison / Outcome — most clinical questions)
> 2. **SPIDER** (Sample / Phenomenon / Design / Evaluation / Research-type — social/qualitative)
> 3. **Decomposition** (Problem / Solution / Evaluation / Limitations — technology-focused)
> 4. **Hybrid** (you pick which components from which framework)
> 5. **You pick** — analyze Q1 and recommend
>
> *Why I'm asking:* PICO is the default for ~70% of clinical questions but maps poorly to qualitative work or technology evaluation. Picking upfront saves the recon search from suggesting a misaligned framework.

Forcing choice with default ("you pick"). The skill surfaces its own framework recommendation after the recon search so user can override. Use `scripts/framework_recommender.py` for the heuristic.

See [`references/framework_selection.md`](references/framework_selection.md) for PICO / SPIDER / Decomposition canon.

### Q3 (depends on Q1) — Tentative depth

> **Tentative depth — pick one. Final confirmation comes after the framework breakdown:**
>
> 1. **Quick scan** (5 searches)
> 2. **Standard review** (10 searches)
> 3. **Deep dive** (20 searches)
>
> *Why I'm asking:* I ask this twice — once now to calibrate the recon search emphasis, once after the framework breakdown to confirm. Tentative answer affects which sub-areas to surface first; final answer drives search budget allocation.

Forcing choice. **Re-asked** at the post-Phase-2 checkpoint after the user has seen the framework breakdown.

**Stop condition:** 3 questions max before Phase 1. The post-Phase-2 checkpoint is its own grill-me moment (framework table + sub-area-adjustment + depth-reconfirmation).

## Phase 1: Initial Reconnaissance

**One broad recon search** to map themes, terminology, methodological distinctions.

- Run the lane check (Consensus available or not), then:
  - Free lane: `python scripts/free_search.py --query "<broad version of Q1>" --source both --max 20` (or the esearch/works URL templates above)
  - **If Consensus is available, additionally** run one broad Consensus search and merge
- Query: broad version of Q1 (terminology variants are okay; first search casts wide)
- Record: `citation_tracker.py --action record_search --session NAME --query "..."`
- Record received count: `citation_tracker.py --action record_papers_received --session NAME --count N`

Synthesize for the checkpoint:
- Themes that surfaced
- Terminology variations (e.g., "LLM" vs "large language model" vs "GPT-style model")
- Methodological distinctions (clinical trials vs benchmark eval vs case study)
- Coverage gaps (sub-questions absent from recon results)

## Phase 2: Framework Selection + Sub-area Generation

Choose framework (from Q2 OR override based on recon):
- **PICO** — most clinical questions (~70% default)
- **SPIDER** — social / qualitative
- **Decomposition** — technology focus (Problem / Solution / Evaluation / Limitations)
- **Hybrid** — explicit cross-framework mapping

Generate **4-5 sub-area questions** mapped to framework components. Each becomes a targeted Phase 3 search.

## Checkpoint (grill-me forcing-options moment)

After Phase 2, halt and present:

### 3-4 sentence recon summary
- What themes surfaced
- Terminology landscape
- Evidence landscape characterization

### Framework breakdown table

| Framework Component | How It Maps to This Topic | Proposed Sub-area to Explore |
|---|---|---|
| (Component 1) | ... | Sub-area 1 |
| (Component 2) | ... | Sub-area 2 |
| (Component 3) | ... | Sub-area 3 |
| (Component 4) | ... | Sub-area 4 |
| Cross-cutting theme | ... | Sub-area 5 |

### Depth re-confirmation (forcing choice)

Surface the **practical constraint**: search lane in use (free / free+Consensus) + approximate ceiling at ~20 results per query per source.

- Quick scan (5 searches × ~20 results = ~100 papers max per source)
- Standard review (10 searches × ~20 = ~200 papers per source)
- Deep dive (20 searches × ~20 = ~400 papers per source)

### Sub-area forcing options

- "Looks good — proceed with these sub-areas"
- "Adjust: add sub-area on [X]"
- "Adjust: remove and replace [Y] with [Z]"
- "Restart with different framework"

### Why I'm asking (the rationale)

> A wrong framework or sub-area set wastes the search budget. This is the **last cheap moment** to correct course.

**Wait for user response before Phase 3.** Refuse to start Phase 3 without explicit user choice.

## Phase 3: Targeted Searches

Sequential (1 query/sec), budget per depth tier. Every search runs on the free lane (`free_search.py` or the URL templates); **if Consensus is available, additionally** run the same query there and merge. See [`references/search_budget_allocation.md`](references/search_budget_allocation.md) for full canon.

### Quick scan (5 searches)
- 5 sub-area searches (one per sub-area)
- Skip era-gated + review-specific

### Standard review (10 searches)
- 5 sub-area searches
- 2 review article searches (top 2 sub-areas): `"systematic review [topic]"` / `"meta-analysis [topic]"` (OpenAlex: add `&filter=type:review`)
- 2 era-gated searches (most important sub-area): historical (PubMed `&maxdate=2015` / OpenAlex `to_publication_date:2015-12-31`) + recent (PubMed `&mindate=2021` / OpenAlex `from_publication_date:2021-01-01`)
- 1 follow-up on highest-cited paper using its key terms + a from-date after its publication year

### Deep dive (20 searches)
- 5 sub-area searches
- 5 review article searches (one per sub-area)
- 4 era-gated searches (top 2 sub-areas, old + new each)
- 3 follow-ups on top 3 highest-cited papers
- 3 spare for emerging threads (surprising findings to chase)

Throughout: 1 q/sec rate limit. Sequential. Confirm response before next call. Record each via `citation_tracker.py`.

## Cross-Search Intelligence

Three trackers across ALL search results — run `scripts/cross_search_aggregator.py --session NAME` after Phase 3 completes:

1. **Repeat-hit papers** — same paper appearing in 3+ sub-area searches = likely foundational
2. **Recurring authors** — same author in multiple searches = dominant research group; top 3-5 most frequent matter
3. **Citation-per-year heuristic** — a 2023 paper with 150 citations >> 2008 paper with 150 citations. Use OpenAlex `cited_by_count` for seminal-work identification.

These feed the "Start Here" + "Key Research Groups" + "Bibliography" DOCX sections.

## Phase 4: DOCX Research Guide

Generate via Node.js + `docx` library. 8 sections (see [`references/docx_8_sections.md`](references/docx_8_sections.md) for full spec):

1. **Topic Overview** — single tight paragraph (4-6 sentences)
2. **Start Here — Priority Reading Order** — 5-7 papers ordered: best recent review → foundational → 2-3 frontier → gap/controversy. Each: hyperlinked title + authors/year + 1-sentence contribution + 1-sentence "what to look for"
3. **How the Field Got Here** — chronological narrative (1-2 paragraphs) + timeline table (5-8 milestones: Year / Milestone / Significance) + terminology evolution note
4. **Sub-area Guides** (one per sub-area, 4 parts each)
   - 4a. What the Research Shows (2-3 sentence synthesis with inline citations)
   - 4b. Key Papers (3-5 hyperlinked papers with citation count, year, 1-sentence importance)
   - 4c. Key Search Terms (6-10 keywords, synonyms, MeSH, historical terms)
   - 4d. Boolean Search Strings (2-3 ready-to-paste strings)
5. **Key Research Groups** — top 3-5 authors/groups with affiliations, sub-area coverage, representative paper link (from cross-search aggregator)
6. **Open Questions & Gaps** — three categories: methodological / population-context / conceptual-theoretical. Each gap explains *why it matters*.
7. **Bibliography** — alphabetical by first author. Every entry has a clickable link: PubMed URL or DOI (free lane) / "View on Consensus" (Consensus-sourced). Every inline citation matches a bibliography entry.
8. **Audit Log** — search summary table (#, query, filters, papers returned, status), counts block, coverage notes including which search lane was used (free / free+Consensus)

### DOCX Technical Requirements

Document the key `docx` library patterns:

- Page: US Letter, 1-inch margins
- Lists: `LevelFormat.BULLET` (never unicode bullets)
- Hyperlinks: `ExternalHyperlink` with `style: "Hyperlink"`, full URL (never truncated)
- Tables: dual widths (`columnWidths` + cell `width`), `ShadingType.CLEAR`
- Validation step after save (zip-integrity check: `python3 -c "import zipfile,sys; zipfile.ZipFile(sys.argv[1]).testzip()" output.docx` — no output = intact — then confirm the required sections are present)

Reference the **docx skill** for setup patterns and best practices.

## Output

```
research_guide_<topic-slug>_<YYYY-MM-DD>.docx
```

Plus:
- Chat summary block: "Saved: <path>. Audit: N searches × M unique papers / K cited. Search lane: <free | free+Consensus>."
- Audit log printed inline if user asks for it

## Tooling

| Script | Role |
|---|---|
| `scripts/free_search.py` | Free keyless search lane — PubMed E-utilities + OpenAlex via stdlib urllib (`--query`, `--source pubmed|openalex|both`, `--max`, `--json`, `--mailto`; exits 2 with a clear message when offline) |
| `scripts/citation_tracker.py` | JSON-backed three-count audit at `~/.litreview_sessions/<session>.json` |
| `scripts/framework_recommender.py` | Heuristic PICO/SPIDER/Decomposition suggestion from research question |
| `scripts/cross_search_aggregator.py` | Repeat-hits + recurring-authors + citation-per-year ranking after Phase 3 |

## References

- [`references/framework_selection.md`](references/framework_selection.md) — PICO / SPIDER / Decomposition canon (7+ sources)
- [`references/search_budget_allocation.md`](references/search_budget_allocation.md) — depth tiers + cross-search intelligence + sequential execution rationale (7+ sources)
- [`references/docx_8_sections.md`](references/docx_8_sections.md) — research guide DOCX spec + technical requirements (7+ sources)

## Anti-Patterns To Reject

- Parallelizing search calls (any lane)
- Skipping the interactive checkpoint (running all searches without user confirmation)
- Padding thin results with training knowledge
- Defaulting to non-PICO framework without justification
- Citing papers in chat that didn't come from this session's searches
- Attempting Consensus plan-tier detection (deleted — the only runtime check is "are the Consensus MCP tools available in this session?")
- Treating Consensus as required (it's an optional enhancement; the free lane is the default)
- Skipping era-gated searches in standard/deep budgets
- Skipping cross-search intelligence (repeat-hits, recurring authors)
- Truncating source URLs in hyperlinks

---

**Version:** 1.1.0
**Source spec:** `megaprompts/09-litreview-megaprompt.md` (maintainer-local draft spec — gitignored, not present in the public repository)
**Build pattern:** Path B (direct conversion). Sibling of `pulse` (research-pack shape). v1.1.0: free keyless APIs (PubMed + OpenAlex) became the default search lane; Consensus demoted to optional enhancement; plan-tier detection deleted per the 2026-06 newgen audit + ClawHub rule #3 (no paid-service dependencies).

---

## Source and license

Original skill: https://github.com/alirezarezvani/claude-skills/blob/4680893d91f2aee6f77ca1519fd1b86b7a104c87/research/litreview/skills/litreview/SKILL.md

Complete source directory: https://github.com/alirezarezvani/claude-skills/tree/4680893d91f2aee6f77ca1519fd1b86b7a104c87/research/litreview/skills/litreview

This catalog copy preserves the original instructions. Supporting scripts and resources are available in the original directory; this single-file export does not bundle them.

MIT License

Copyright (c) 2025 Alireza Rezvani

Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy
of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal
in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights
to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell
copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is
furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR
IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM,
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE
SOFTWARE.

使用示例

请使用「文献综述整理」技能处理下面的任务。

目标:围绕研究问题组织文献、比较方法和结论,保留引用与未解决问题。
输入材料:研究问题、已知资料、比较对象、证据范围和判断标准。
输出要求:区分事实、假设与推断;按证据组织结论,列出局限和下一步验证建议。

请先核对所需资料和工具;缺少关键信息时提出具体问题。涉及对外发布、删除或生产环境变更时,先提供可审查的计划,获得授权后再执行。

关注官方公众号

抢先获取热门 Skill 实操干货、产品更新与官方活动资讯。

官方交流群二维码

加入官方交流群

对接创作者与同好,交流技能开发,共建 AI 技能生态。