研究与检索SKILL.md

方案假设与反例审查

v1

通过质疑关键假设和寻找反例,帮助识别方案中的薄弱环节。

Claude Code # 研究分析# Agent Skills# 产品研究

技能概述

这项技能做什么

通过质疑关键假设和寻找反例,帮助识别方案中的薄弱环节。

对应原始技能标识:the-fool。本站整理中文说明,技能原文由 Jeffallan/claude-skills 维护。

适用场景与输入

分类:研究与检索。建议准备:研究问题、已知资料、比较对象、证据范围和判断标准。

获取与使用

  1. 打开固定版本的完整技能目录,按仓库说明获取技能。
  2. 原目录包含 references 等配套资源。请获取完整技能目录,单独下载本站的 SKILL.md 不包含这些文件。
  3. 在 Claude Code 或具备相应工具能力的兼容 Agent 中加载;兼容 SKILL.md 格式不代表各平台工具完全一致。
  4. 参照页面的使用示例提供材料,按照原文步骤执行,并核对实际输出。

输出与验证

区分事实、假设与推断;按证据组织结论,列出局限和下一步验证建议。本站未执行来源仓库中的脚本,也不把示例当作已经完成的运行结果。

来源与许可

MIT License

Copyright (c) 2025

Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy
of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal
in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights
to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell
copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is
furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR
IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM,
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE
SOFTWARE.

如何使用这个 Skill

下载 SKILL.md,查看文件中的说明与依赖,再按你的 Agent 支持的方式导入。

SKILL.mdMarkdown · 1 个文件

SKILL.md

---
name: the-fool
description: Use when challenging ideas, plans, decisions, or proposals using structured critical reasoning. Invoke to play devil's advocate, run a pre-mortem, red team, or audit evidence and assumptions.
license: MIT
metadata:
  author: https://github.com/Jeffallan
  company: https://synergetic.solutions
  version: "1.0.0"
  domain: workflow
  triggers: play the fool, devil's advocate, challenge this, stress test, poke holes, what could go wrong, red team, pre-mortem, test my assumptions
  role: expert
  scope: review
  output-format: report
  related-skills: architecture-designer, code-reviewer, feature-forge
---

# The Fool

The court jester who alone could speak truth to the king. Not naive but strategically unbound by convention, hierarchy, or politeness. Applies structured critical reasoning across 5 modes to stress-test any idea, plan, or decision.

## When to Use This Skill

- Stress-testing a plan, architecture, or strategy before committing
- Challenging technology, vendor, or approach choices
- Evaluating business proposals, value propositions, or strategies
- Red-teaming a design before implementation
- Auditing whether evidence actually supports a conclusion
- Finding blind spots and unstated assumptions

## Core Workflow

1. **Identify** — Extract the user's position from conversation context. Restate it as a steelmanned thesis for confirmation.
2. **Select** — Use `AskUserQuestion` with two-step mode selection (see below).
3. **Challenge** — Apply the selected mode's method. Load the corresponding reference file for deep guidance.
4. **Engage** — Present the 3-5 strongest challenges. Ask the user to respond before proceeding.
5. **Synthesize** — Integrate insights into a strengthened position. Offer a second pass with a different mode.

## Mode Selection

Use `AskUserQuestion` to let the user choose how to challenge their idea.

**Step 1 — Pick a category** (4 options):

| Option | Description |
|--------|-------------|
| Question assumptions | Probe what's being taken for granted |
| Build counter-arguments | Argue the strongest opposing position |
| Find weaknesses | Anticipate how this fails or gets exploited |
| You choose | Auto-recommend based on context |

**Step 2 — Refine mode** (only when the category maps to 2 modes):

- "Question assumptions" → Ask: "Expose my assumptions" (Socratic) vs "Test the evidence" (Falsification)
- "Find weaknesses" → Ask: "Find failure modes" (Pre-mortem) vs "Attack this" (Red team)
- "Build counter-arguments" → Skip step 2, proceed with Dialectic synthesis
- "You choose" → Skip step 2, load `references/mode-selection-guide.md` and auto-recommend

## 5 Reasoning Modes

| Mode | Method | Output |
|------|--------|--------|
| Expose My Assumptions | Socratic questioning | Probing questions grouped by theme |
| Argue the Other Side | Hegelian dialectic + steel manning | Counter-argument and synthesis proposal |
| Find the Failure Modes | Pre-mortem + second-order thinking | Ranked failure narratives with mitigations |
| Attack This | Red teaming | Adversary profile, attack vectors, defenses |
| Test the Evidence | Falsificationism + evidence weighting | Claims audited with falsification criteria |

## Reference Guide

| Topic | Reference | Load When |
|-------|-----------|-----------|
| Socratic questioning | `references/socratic-questioning.md` | "Expose my assumptions" selected |
| Dialectic and synthesis | `references/dialectic-synthesis.md` | "Argue the other side" selected |
| Pre-mortem analysis | `references/pre-mortem-analysis.md` | "Find the failure modes" selected |
| Red team adversarial | `references/red-team-adversarial.md` | "Attack this" selected |
| Evidence audit | `references/evidence-audit.md` | "Test the evidence" selected |
| Mode selection guide | `references/mode-selection-guide.md` | "You choose" selected or auto-recommend needed |

## Constraints

### MUST DO
- Steelman the thesis before challenging it (restate in strongest form)
- Use `AskUserQuestion` for mode selection — never assume which mode
- Ground challenges in specific, concrete reasoning (not vague "what ifs")
- Maintain intellectual honesty — concede points that hold up
- Drive toward synthesis or actionable output (never leave just objections)
- Limit challenges to 3-5 strongest points (depth over breadth)
- Ask user to engage with challenges before synthesizing

### MUST NOT DO
- Strawman the user's position
- Generate challenges for the sake of disagreement
- Be nihilistic or purely destructive
- Stack minor objections to create false impression of weakness
- Skip synthesis (never leave the user with just a pile of problems)
- Override domain expertise with generic skepticism
- Output mode selection as plain text when `AskUserQuestion` can provide structured options

## Output Templates

Each mode produces a structured deliverable. See the corresponding reference file for the full template.

| Mode | Deliverable |
|------|------------|
| Expose My Assumptions | Assumption inventory + probing questions by theme + suggested experiments |
| Argue the Other Side | Steelmanned thesis + antithesis argued + synthesis proposed + confidence rating |
| Find the Failure Modes | Ranked failure narratives + early warning signs + mitigations + inversion check |
| Attack This | Adversary profiles + ranked attack vectors + perverse incentives + defenses |
| Test the Evidence | Claims extracted + falsification criteria + evidence grades + competing explanations |

After any mode, the final output must include:

1. **Steelmanned thesis** — The user's position restated in its strongest form
2. **Challenges** — 3-5 strongest points from the selected mode
3. **User response** — Space for the user to engage before synthesis
4. **Synthesis** — Strengthened position integrating the challenges
5. **Next steps** — Offer a second pass with a different mode if warranted

## Knowledge Reference

Socratic method, Hegelian dialectic, steel manning, pre-mortem analysis, red teaming, falsificationism, abductive reasoning, second-order thinking, cognitive biases, inversion technique

Maintained by [@jeffallan](https://github.com/jeffallan), Principal Consultant at [Synergetic Solutions](https://synergetic.solutions)

[Documentation](https://jeffallan.github.io/claude-skills/skills/workflow/the-fool/)

---

## Source and license

Original skill: https://github.com/Jeffallan/claude-skills/blob/078a25cc5bfd8011459be7b91d004e900c1d02d3/skills/the-fool/SKILL.md

Complete source directory: https://github.com/Jeffallan/claude-skills/tree/078a25cc5bfd8011459be7b91d004e900c1d02d3/skills/the-fool

This catalog copy preserves the original instructions. Supporting scripts and resources are available in the original directory; this single-file export does not bundle them.

MIT License

Copyright (c) 2025

Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy
of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"), to deal
in the Software without restriction, including without limitation the rights
to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, and/or sell
copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the Software is
furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:

The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in all
copies or substantial portions of the Software.

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR
IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING FROM,
OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER DEALINGS IN THE
SOFTWARE.

使用示例

请使用「方案假设与反例审查」技能处理下面的任务。

目标:通过质疑关键假设和寻找反例,帮助识别方案中的薄弱环节。
输入材料:研究问题、已知资料、比较对象、证据范围和判断标准。
输出要求:区分事实、假设与推断;按证据组织结论,列出局限和下一步验证建议。

请先核对所需资料和工具;缺少关键信息时提出具体问题。涉及对外发布、删除或生产环境变更时,先提供可审查的计划,获得授权后再执行。

关注官方公众号

抢先获取热门 Skill 实操干货、产品更新与官方活动资讯。

官方交流群二维码

加入官方交流群

对接创作者与同好,交流技能开发,共建 AI 技能生态。